How about that — The Roches have a new record coming out. Their first release in a decade. Their classic 1979 debut disc remains the best introduction to their sound: three women with wonderful, gravity-defying voices singing quirky, ruefully funny songs. On their later records, the sisters sometimes tipped over into the terminally twee; on the debut, the cuteness was held in check by the spartan arrangements and bright sound engineered by the producer, Robert Fripp.
Eric Alterman, also a fan of the group, ran this note from Suzzy Roche in his blog Altercation. I didn’t know whether to laugh or to snort at this:
When we made our debut record, Robert Fripp, its producer, said, “You’ll never make a cent, but you will influence people.” Looking back, I understand what he meant, and I feel that Moonswept goes farther in that direction. A funny thing about doing this kind of work is that as insignificant as something feels, the opposite is also true.
Fripp can talk — he just has to regroup King Crimson whenever he needs to pay off his credit card balance. Still, on the debut disc and on the third Roches album, Keep On Doing, he showed an understanding of the group that no other producer could match.
Of course, the Roches themselves always seemed aware that obscurity was just around the corner. In fact, they made that awareness a cornerstone for some of their best songs. To this day, whenever I suffer a career or creative reversal, I think of ”Mr. Sellack,” a song about trying to get your old job back after crashing and burning in your grand ambitions:
O Mr Sellack
Can I have my job back?
I’ve run out of money again.
Last time I saw ya
I was singing Hallelujah
I’m so glad to be leavin’ this restaurant.
Now the only thing I want
Is to have my old job back again.
I’ll clean the tables;
I’ll do the creams;
I’ll get down on my knees and scrub
behind the steam table.
O Mr. Sellack
I didn’t think I’d be back.
I worked here last year
Remember?
I came when Annie
Was going on vacation
And I stayed on almost till December.
Now the only thing I want
Is to have my old job back again.
I won’t be nasty to customers no more.
When they send their burger back I’ll tell them that
I’m sorry.
Waiting tables ain’t that bad.
Since I’ve seen you last, I’ve waited
for some things that you would not believe
To come true.
Give me a broom and I’ll sweep my way to heaven.
Give me a job;
You name it.
Let the other forty-million three-hundred and seven
People who want to get famous.
Now the only thing I want
Is to have that old job back again.
I’ll clean the tables;
I’ll do the creams;
I’ll get down on my knees and scrub
behind the steam table.
Fripp’s line about being influential reminds me of the old saw about the Velvet Underground: Very few people bought their records, but the ones who did all started bands. I don’t know how influential the Roches turned out to be. I know that in 2007, the idea of three women recording an album of virtually unaccompanied singing doesn’t sound nearly as novel and daring as it did in 1979.
That was always the glory of The Roches: after trying to glitz up their sound as per music industry formula, they pulled back and realized that even if they were never going to be more than a niche act, they would fill their own niche. That DIY spirit now suffuses the music scene as the recording industry does its best to choke off challenging and unexpected music.
It’s taken more than a quarter of a century, but the world has caught up with the Roches. Maybe that example is their biggest influence on music. Not a bad legacy, when you think about it. But the music is pretty great, too, and I look forward to renewing the acquaintance.