So now it’s been just over forty years since the Beatles put out Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band and the inevitable anniversary stories are done with. Am I allowed to say that as much as I love the Beatles, and as important as they remain in the annals of popular music, I think Sgt. Pepper is a weak, gimmicky record? Or that I think it led rock music down an ill-advised cul-de-sac? Well, there, I said it anyway.
My answer to the old question “Who’s your favorite Beatle” has always been “John Lennon,” and Sgt. Pepper is very much Paul’s record. Sgt. Pepper really hasn’t stood up to the years as commandingly as the band’s other releases, because the songwriting that was always the band’s calling card (as opposed to instrumental virtuosity or great vocals) took a significant step back from Revolver. It all sounds as wonderful as ever, but except for “With A Little Help From My Friends,” “When I’m 64″ and “For the Benefit of Mister Kite” the songs are at best minor additions to the Beatles catalogue. The exception, of course, is “A Day in the Life,” the menacing masterpiece that is the real reason Sgt. Pepper holds its place in the popular imagination.
Even when my Beatles obsession was at its height, Sgt. Pepper was hardly ever the album I reached for when I wanted some of their music. I would go for Revolver, which showcased all three songwriters in the band (George having finally come into his own), or A Hard Day’s Night (pure up from the first note, the high water mark of the group’s initial phase as John Lennon’s band), or the white album (Lennon’s first real solo album, with guest spots by the other boys). In my perfect musical universe, Sgt. Pepper would be edited down and built back up with the choicer cuts from Magical Mystery Tour: “Penny Lane,” “Your Mother Should Know,” “Strawberry Fields,” “Fool on the Hill,” “Blue Jay Way.” “I Am the Walrus” would replace “Mister Kite” as the closer for side one, and a forecast of what’s to come with “A Day in the Life.”
Sgt. Pepper marked the end of the three-way competition of giants that enlivened 1960s rock and roll. It started with Bob Dylan, whose second album The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan served as the model for the Beatles as they became more ambitious songwriters, and included the Rolling Stones, who were late to develop their own songwriting skills but quickly made up for lost time. What followed was a wonderful game of Can You Top This? as they tried to outdo each other, with all of us the winners. It ended with Sgt. Pepper. Dylan, who despised the self-indulgent gimmickry of psychedelic rock, turned around and recorded the defiantly anti-psychedelic John Wesley Harding. The Stones, always a few steps behind the Beatles, released the slavishly imitative Their Satanic Majesties Request before high-tailing it back to their signature sound on Beggar’s Banquet. The chief beneficiaries of Sgt. Pepper were the members of the Moody Blues, who decided to chuck their fading R&B-based sound and run with the trippy concept album template the Beatles had created.
Back in the vinyl days, pausing to admire the play of light along the bands that marked each song was part of the whole Japanese tea ceremony that accompanied the placement of a disc on the turntable. You could always tell a much-played album from its scratches and dulled surface. But on every copy of Sgt. Pepper, no matter how worn and overplayed, the band for George Harrison’s dreary sitar-droning song always gleamed as if it were fresh from the pressing plant.