Gardnerwulf

I really didn’t want to write anything else about the Robert Zemeckis-directed Beowulf: as I already explained, I didn’t much like it. It seems to be making a bit of money, so I guess it’ll be just a matter of time before we see Gilgamesh starring a CGI-encrusted The Rock, with Denise Richards as Ninsun and a cameo appearance by Billy Crystal as Urshanabi. Whatever.

But now I see that Roger Avary, who co-wrote the screenplay with Neil Gaiman, appears to think he pulled off something wild and outrageous. So let me introduce this piker to Jeff Sypeck and Doc Nokes, who point out that the idea of making Grendel into a misunderstood misanthrope instead of a ravening enemy of decency is not terribly original or daring. This leads to an interesting discussion of John Gardner’s 1971 novel Grendel, which was the first attempt to ring a few changes on the nature of Heorot’s unwelcome guest:

Like many a postmodern protagonist, Grendel embodies the intellectual trends of the day, but he’s not some whining prep-school antihero or an English professor coping with a midlife crisis; rather, he’s a creature of consequence. Julie Taymor has suggested of Grendel that “the monster is the most human of humans,” but I don’t think she’s right. Instead, he’s a truly wretched creature: an abomination cobbled together from the spare parts of modernity—a monster made insane by modernity itself.

There’s much more to say about Grendel, and I suspect my students, an increasingly candid bunch, will surprise and enlighten me with perspectives that aren’t stuck in 1971. Accustomed to other novels that sincerely praise nonconformity, they’ll probably notice, without my prompting, that Grendel isn’t just the story of a sensitive rebel, a Morrissey with bloody claws.

Grendel is a work of stark medievalism. It expresses little sympathy for the prejudices of the modern wit and outright disdain for the fatal affectations of the anti-hero. This Grendel is misunderstood—every time a reader assumes he ought to be seen as something other than the embodiment of doctrines that presumably rot the modern mind. Forget the conventional wisdom: Far from being a postmodern paean to the moody outcast, John Gardner’s Grendel may, in fact, be one of the most reactionary novels an English major will ever read.

I’ve always been puzzled by the appearance of Grendel on high school reading lists — Gardner’s novel assumes deep knowledge of the original poem, which would seem to be plenty enough work in itself. (There’s an animated version of the novel out there that I’d like to track down sometime.) Perhaps Roger Avary and Neil Gaiman should be required to take a few night classes on the topic, as penance.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Gardnerwulf

  1. Jeff says:

    It’s funny: usually I’d complain that the lazy creators of pop culture need to spend more time looking beyond their usual sources (i.e., other iterations of pop culture), but in this case, Avary would have benefited from looking at the various Beowulf-derived films and novels of the past 30 years. The monster with a legitimate grudge, the twisted family issues, the skepticism about the heroic code, the supposed unreliability of narrative…all of these issues have been done before, sometimes interestingly, sometimes not, especially in a couple of fantasy novels. That said, Avary’s comments at least make me better understand the pointless bluster of much of the movie.

  2. Quid plura? says:

    […] Welcome, new readers!  Whether you’re here from 2Blowhards, Urban Prowlers, StumbledUpon, StevenHartSite, or Unlocked Wordhoard, I hope you’ll stop back occasionally if you’re interested in […]

  3. sm says:

    There is a lot of “pointless bluster” in the movies caused by the tendency of directors and producers to redo the movies they loved when they were 8. If they do anything different at all with the source material, they are very impressed with themselves.

  4. […] Welcome, new readers!  Whether you’re here from 2Blowhards, Urban Prowlers, StumbledUpon, StevenHartSite, or Unlocked Wordhoard, I hope you’ll stop back occasionally if you’re interested in […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: